The Best Screw Extractors

Shelly Anderson
16 min readApr 19, 2024

--

Screw-Extractor-1

Get ready to dive into the world of screw extractors — the ultimate solution for those pesky stripped or damaged screws that have been giving you grief. In this article, we’ll take a closer look at some of the best screw extractors on the market and provide you with a roundup of the top picks. Whether you’re a professional handyman or just a DIY enthusiast, we’ve got you covered with our comprehensive guide to these nifty tools.

The Top 10 Best Screw Extractors

  1. 5-Piece Double Edge Screw Extractor Set by Knipex — Remove the toughest fasteners without damaging threads with the versatile 5-piece Screw Extractor Set by Knipex, suitable for both left and right handed threads and perfect for all your engineering needs.
  2. Spiral-Flute Extractor Set for Removing Broken Screws, Bolts, and Fittings — Effortlessly remove broken studs and bolts with the Irwin Spiral-Flute Extractor 6-Piece Set, featuring an aggressive left-hand spiral design for extra grip and durability.
  3. Alden Micro Grabit Screw Extractor #8 — The Alden Micro Grabit Broken Bolt Extractor #8 is a strong, self-centering, and versatile screw extractor designed for jagged and uneven breaks, perfect for those looking to make multiple extractions without using additional tools.
  4. 26 PCS Screw&Bolt Extractor/Drill Bit Set with Reverse Spiral Groove — RIMKOLO’s 26-piece Screw Extractors and Drill Bit Set delivers high-quality tools for efficiently removing damaged bolts, nuts, and broken screws with ease, thanks to reverse spiral groove design, sturdy materials, and anti-corrosion features.
  5. Qualtech Sturdy Carbon Steel Screw Extractor — Strengthen your DIY toolkit with the Qualtech Dewez2 #2 Carbon Steel Screw Extractor, the top-rated extractor for easily removing seized screws with its robust, hardened carbon steel construction and left hand spiral flute.
  6. Durable SAE Screw Extractor Set — Pittsburgh Professional removes stubborn nuts and bolts effortlessly, making it the perfect screw extractor in your toolbox!
  7. Titan Damaged Bolt Extractor Ring Set — Effortlessly remove damaged bolts with the Titan 16058 5-Piece Disposable Damaged Bolt Extractor Ring Set, featuring sizes from 15 to 19mm and a durable, reusable construction.
  8. XJX 31-Piece Bolt Extractor Set with Titanium Coating and Multiple Size Models — The XJX 31-Piece Screw Extractors is an all-in-one solution for removing broken bolts, nuts, and screws made from high-quality materials for durability and versatility.
  9. XEWEA 25-Piece Chrome Screw Extractor Set for Loosened Bolts — Strength meets versatility with the XEWEA Bolt Extractor Set, featuring high-quality CR-MO steel, easy-out design, and a range of sizes for various screws, perfect for home, mechanical, or telecom maintenance.
  10. Heavy-Duty Bolt Extractor Set for Removing Broken Studs and Bolts — The RIMKOLO 25-Piece Screw Extractor Set, featuring a heat-treated hexagon head multi-spline design, is a versatile and efficient tool for removing broken studs, bolts, and pins, making it a must-have for any mechanic’s tool kit.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Reviews

5-Piece Double Edge Screw Extractor Set by Knipex

knipex-9r4719003-rennsteig-5-piece-double-edge-screw-extractor-set-1

Gathering up my Knipex 9R4719003 Rennsteig 5-Piece Double Edge Screw Extractor Set on a recent weekend project, I was delighted to discover the versatility of this compact, 5-piece screw extractor set. With just the right mix of sizes, from #1 to #5, this set seemed to cover all the common extraction needs — whether it be bolts or screws. What stands out, though, is the impressive non-slip, double edge engagement. This feature makes all the difference in tackling the toughest fasteners.

Couple it with the large hex-head surface that provides an outstanding grip, and you’ve got a tool that is not only efficient, but also comfortable to use. Not to mention, it is ambidextrous which is a thoughtful feature that can be of great benefit to both right- and left-handed individuals.

The large hex head design is not just for aesthetics, it enhances the grip and rotation of the handle, making the overall usage more efficient. It also has an integrated centre point for precise drilling — a feature that ensures accuracy and reduces the potential for error, adding efficiency and precision to my DIY projects. Moreover, it comes in a neat vinyl pouch — offering a stylish and practical solution to product storage.

Now, down to the not-so-great aspect. At just 1 lb, it’s quite lightweight which can somewhat be perceived as an inconvenience for more serious DIYers and mechanics. It might slip from one’s hand during a heavier task, something a bit more sturdy would have been appreciated.

Overall, though, I’d recommend the Knipex 9R4719003 Rennsteig 5-Piece Double Edge Screw Extractor Set to DIYers and professionals looking for a versatile, easy-to-use tool that won’t break the bank. It’s a handy set that should be part of every toolkit.

Spiral-Flute Extractor Set for Removing Broken Screws, Bolts, and Fittings

irwin-spiral-flute-extractor-6-piece-set-1

I recently had the chance to try out the Irwin Spiral-Flute Extractor 6-Piece Set, and I must say, it certainly made a difference in my daily life. As someone who often finds themselves needing to remove broken screws or bolts, this tool proved to be extremely useful.

One of the things that stood out to me was the aggressive left-hand spiral design, which really enhanced the extractor’s grip. This was particularly helpful when trying to remove stubborn fittings or fasteners. Another great feature was the clear, permanent extractor size and recommended drill bit stamps, which made tool selection a breeze.

However, I did encounter a slight issue with one of the extractors breaking after repeated usage. It was a minor inconvenience, but nothing that couldn’t be fixed with a quick replacement. Additionally, some of the instructions could have been more clear, as I found myself somewhat confused when trying to select the appropriate drill bit for a particular task.

Overall, though, I was very pleased with the Irwin Spiral-Flute Extractor 6-Piece Set. It’s a reliable and durable tool that has made my life much easier when it comes to those pesky broken screws and bolts. Highly recommended for anyone who frequently encounters this kind of issue.

Alden Micro Grabit Screw Extractor #8

alden-micro-grabit-broken-bolt-extractor-8-1

As a product reviewer, I’ve found myself in need of a tool that could handle broken bolts efficiently, and Alden Micro’s Grabit Broken Bolt Extractor truly stood out. The self-centering drill tip eliminates the usual hassle of walking or wandering when extracting, and the unique design allows the tool to stay on center.

Best of all, there’s no need for center punching, pilot holes, or grinding, making it a breeze to use in various situations. The tool’s extra hardness, thanks to being tempered twice, also ensures multiple extractions per tool.

With an M4-№8 screw diameter and a combination drill bit/extractor, this is a versatile tool to have in one’s arsenal, especially when dealing with jagged, uneven, and rough breaks. The dimension of 0.56 inches by 1.88 by 3.88 inches, coupled with its lightweight at 0.1 lb, makes it convenient to carry and use. Overall, the Alden Micro Grabit Broken Bolt Extractor has been a reliable companion for me, offering exceptional performance and a hassle-free experience.

26 PCS Screw&Bolt Extractor/Drill Bit Set with Reverse Spiral Groove

rimkolo-26-piece-screw-extractors-and-drill-bit-set-multi-spline-extractors-bolt-extractors-drill-bi-1

The Rimkollo 26-piece screw extractor and drill bit set is a versatile toolkit designed to handle a wide range of fasteners, with 6 spiral flute extractors for easy removal and 13 bolt and nut extractors. This set also includes a 1/4'’ hex adapter and 6 drill bits. The nut remover/spiral screw extractor is crafted from high hardness chrome-molybdenum steel, providing exceptional durability and performance.

The reverse spiral groove design ensures maximum grip force, making it simple to extract damaged bolts, nuts, and broken screws. The right-hand drill bit offers strong penetration thanks to its HHS construction and 135-degree angle head, which is resistant to wear.

Additionally, titanium nitride coating offers effective corrosion and rust protection, extending the lifespan of the product.

Qualtech Sturdy Carbon Steel Screw Extractor

qualtech-dewez2-2-carbon-steel-screw-extractor-1

Introducing the Qualtech Dewez2 #2 Carbon Steel Screw Extractor — a perfect solution for tackling those pesky broken or seized screws in your life. This trusty extractor boasts an impressive 4.8-star rating and 4.0 reviews from satisfied customers, demonstrating its high quality and unbeatable performance. Crafted from durable hardened carbon steel, it’s designed specifically to make screw removal easier, thanks to its left-hand spiral flute. Plus, it’s priced right for an item of this caliber.

With a cutting direction of left-hand and a drill size of 7/64, this extractor offers just the right touch to remove even the most stubborn screws. Equipped with a straight flute, it’s perfect to grab onto and twist away. The extraction power doesn’t stop there — with an overall length of 2–3/8 inches, and a screw size capacity of up to 1/4 inches, it’s equipped to handle a wide range of tasks.

Despite the uncoated (bright) finish, customers rave about the fast and reliable service they have received. So, why wait? Dive into the world of hassle-free screw removal with the Qualtech Dewez2 #2 Carbon Steel Screw Extractor — a must-have addition to any DIY enthusiast’s toolbox.

Durable SAE Screw Extractor Set

pittsburgh-professional-9-piece-3-8-drive-sae-bolt-extractor-sockets-1

A couple of weeks ago, I had a frustrating experience trying to remove a stripped bolt from an old piece of furniture. That’s when I decided to give the Pittsburgh Professional 9 Piece 3/8" Drive SAE Bolt Extractor Sockets a try.

At first, I was a bit skeptical about these bolt extractor sockets. They looked pretty simple and there were no “highlights” mentioned. But after using them, I was pleasantly surprised at how these little guys made my life easier.

First, let’s talk about their design. They are built with a specialized internal mechanism that grabs and grips fasteners for quick and straightforward removal. I couldn’t believe how easy it was to extract the bolt without damaging the surrounding material. Just one twist, and the bolt came out, no sweat.

The other thing I loved about this product was the highly visible markings on the sockets. No more guessing which socket to use, the markings made it clear. I tried to strip the bolt again for the sake of this review, and it was as easy as the first time.

However, there was one downside I noticed. These sockets are pretty tight-fitting, which can sometimes make it difficult to get them in place. But once they’re in there, they do their job very well.

Overall, the Pittsburgh Professional 9 Piece 3/8" Drive SAE Bolt Extractor Sockets are a lifesaver. They’ve become a staple in my toolbox, and I highly recommend them to anyone who needs to extract bolts with ease. Despite the minor fit issue, the pros outweigh the cons, and they definitely deserve a spot in anyone’s toolbox.

Titan Damaged Bolt Extractor Ring Set

titan-16058-5-piece-disposable-damaged-bolt-extractor-ring-set-1

Introducing the Titan 16058 5-Piece Disposable Damaged Bolt Extractor Ring Set, perfect for those times when you need to extract a stubborn bolt that’s been damaged or stripped. This set includes sizes 15, 16, 17, 18, and 19mm, which can also fit 5/8 and 3/4-Inch bolts.

Each bolt extractor ring forms to the damaged hardware, making it easy to remove the damaged bolts. To make the most of these extractors, use a 12-point wrench or socket that’s 2mm larger than the bolt size. The great thing about these extractors is that they are reusable — simply remove them by hand or with a punch if necessary.

Made of durable materials, including alloy steel with a black manganese phosphate finish, this set is constructed in Taiwan. So, whether you’re a professional mechanic or a DIY automobile enthusiast, the Titan 16058 5-Piece Disposable Damaged Bolt Extractor Ring Set is a valuable addition to your toolbox.

XJX 31-Piece Bolt Extractor Set with Titanium Coating and Multiple Size Models

xjx-31-piece-screw-extractors-easy-out-bolt-extractor-set-drill-bit-set-multi-spline-screw-extractor-1

When you’re stuck with a stubborn bolt, the XJX 31-Piece Screw Extractors Bolt Extractor Set is your trusted companion. This versatile set is built with premium materials, with high speed steel drill bits and chromium molybdenum steel extractor kit, ensuring maximum durability and toughness.

I particularly love the reverse spiral groove design that provides a firm grip, making those tricky extractions a breeze. Plus, the 135-degree cutting angle with a titanium surface coating adds the icing on the cake, providing enhanced accessibility and longevity. And don’t worry about those pesky stripped, rusted, or frozen screws — the set makes short work of them.

With a wide range of SAE sizes available, it’s a must-have for DIY enthusiasts and professionals alike.

XEWEA 25-Piece Chrome Screw Extractor Set for Loosened Bolts

xewea-25pcs-screw-extractor-set-hex-head-multi-spline-easy-out-bolt-extractor-set-chrome-molybdenum--1

As an avid DIY enthusiast, I recently had the chance to try out the XEWEA screw extractor set from the Chrome Molybdenum Alloy Steel Heavy Duty Bolt Remover. I was immediately impressed by the high quality of the set and the durability of the CR-MO steel. The left-hand spiral design provides excellent grip, allowing me to quickly and easily extract even the most stubborn screws. The wide range of sizes included in the set makes it versatile and suitable for a variety of different screws.

One downside I did notice was that the rounded edges on some of the extractors could be a bit sharper, but it didn’t hinder my ability to use the set effectively. Despite this minor drawback, the XEWEA screw extractor set proved to be a valuable tool in my arsenal for home repairs and mechanical maintenance.

Heavy-Duty Bolt Extractor Set for Removing Broken Studs and Bolts

rimkolo-25-piece-screw-extractor-set-multi-spline-extractor-set-easy-out-bolt-extractors-cr-mo-bolt--1

Recently, I had the chance to try out the RIMKOLO 25-Piece Screw Extractor Set. As someone who frequently works on DIY projects, I found this set incredibly helpful in dealing with those seemingly impossible-to-remove bolts.

The unique multi-spline design made it a breeze to get the job done, and I was impressed with the sturdy build of the set. However, I did find that the carrying case could have been a bit more durable to withstand the wear and tear of everyday use. Overall, this extractor set was a worthwhile investment for my toolbox.

Buyer’s Guide

When it comes to repairing or disassembling furniture, appliances, or machinery, having the right screw extractor can make all the difference. But with so many options available, it can be challenging to determine which one is best for your needs. In this buyer’s guide, we’ll go over important features, considerations, and advice to help you choose the right screw extractor for your projects.

Screw-Extractor-2

Types of Screw Extractors

There are different types of screw extractors, each with its own advantages and disadvantages. Some of the most common include manual extractors, electric extractors, and specialized extraction tools like socket extractors and star bits. Consider the type of project you’re working on and the accessibility of the damaged screw before selecting the right tool for the job.

Material and Durability

Material plays a significant role in the durability and performance of a screw extractor. Look for tools made from high-quality materials, such as steel or titanium, which can withstand heavy use and resist corrosion. Additionally, consider the construction of the extractor, looking for models with rust-resistant coatings and sturdy handles.

Screw-Extractor-3

Size and Capacity

The size and capacity of a screw extractor are essential factors to consider, especially when working with various screw sizes. A tool with a range of sizes and a locking mechanism will ensure that the extracted screw is securely held in place during the extraction process. Look for models with interchangeable heads or multiple sizes in one tool to enhance versatility.

Grip and Control

A solid grip and precise control are crucial for effective screw extraction. Look for tools with ergonomic handles and knurled grips for a secure hold. Additionally, a ratcheting mechanism or a locking system can provide added control and prevent the screw from slipping during the extraction process. It’s also essential to consider the tool’s weight and balance to ensure comfort when using it for extended periods.

Screw-Extractor-4

FAQ

What is a screw extractor and how does it work?

A screw extractor is a tool designed to remove stripped or damaged screws from various surfaces. It typically consists of a pair of pliers with interchangeable tips that fit into the screw’s head, allowing users to grip and twist it out, even when standard screwdrivers cannot. There are manual and power-driven options available to suit different project requirements.

The extractor works by gripping the screw head with a strong clamping force and then twisting it out, often with the help of a reversible drill or a power drill. Some models come with an included motorized handle for added convenience and efficiency in removing stubborn screws. Overall, a screw extractor makes it possible to save and reuse screws without causing further damage to the surface they were originally installed on.

Screw-Extractor-5

What are the benefits of using a screw extractor?

The primary benefit of using a screw extractor is the ability to efficiently remove stripped or damaged screws without causing additional damage to the surrounding material. This can be especially useful in delicate applications such as working with wooden furniture, where using brute force may result in further damage. Moreover, using a screw extractor reduces the need for replacement screws, making the process more cost-effective.

Using a screw extractor also simplifies repairs and installations, as it allows technicians, DIY enthusiasts, and homeowners to remove and replace hardware quickly, without compromising the integrity of the material. In addition, a screw extractor is a versatile tool suitable for various applications, from automotive to electronics, and can potentially replace multiple specialized tools. As such, it’s a practical investment for many users seeking a reliable and efficient solution for their screw problem-solving needs.

What types of screw extractors are available in the market?

There are different types of screw extractors available on the market, with variations in design, materials, and functionality. Some common categories include manual extractors, battery-powered and cordless extractors, and electric extractors with the included motorized handle. Each type is best suited for various applications, depending on user preferences, project requirements, and work environment. Be sure to consider factors such as ease of use, power source, compatibility with different screw types, and the extractor’s overall durability when choosing the right model for your needs.

When selecting a screw extractor, it’s crucial to look for a tool that offers a balance between affordability and performance, ensuring you’ll be able to tackle any stripped or damaged screw situation effectively. Read reviews, compare specifications, and consider your budget to narrow down your options and find the perfect screw extractor for your intended use.

Screw-Extractor-6

Are there screw extractors available for different screw sizes and materials?

Yes, most screw extractors are designed to accommodate various screw sizes and materials, ensuring that they can be used in a wide range of applications. Some screw extractors may come with multiple grip-tip sizes to accommodate different screw heads, while others may incorporate flexible, adjustable tips that can adapt to different screw shapes and sizes.

It’s essential to pay attention to the product specifications when choosing a screw extractor, as this will determine its versatility and effective compatibility with various screw types. Additionally, reading user reviews can help you gauge whether an extractor performs well in removing screws of various sizes and materials. Always remember to ensure that the extractor you choose is suitable for the specific screws you’ll be working with to achieve the best results.

How do I maintain and care for my screw extractor?

Proper maintenance and care of a screw extractor are essential to ensure its longevity and performance. Here are some tips to help you maintain your screw extractor in optimal condition:

  1. Clean the tool after each use to remove any residual dust or debris;
  2. Store the extractor in a dry and secure location, away from direct sunlight and extreme temperatures;
  3. Lubricate moving parts, such as the clamping mechanism and grip, with a high-quality lubricant to prevent rust and corrosion; and 4) Regularly check the tool for wear, and replace any worn or damaged parts as needed.

Following these maintenance guidelines will not only extend the lifespan of your screw extractor but also help to ensure that it continues to perform at its best for years to come. By taking proper care of your tool, you’ll be able to enjoy greater efficiency and ease when removing troublesome screws in any application.

Are there any safety precautions that I should take while using a screw extractor?

Yes, there are several safety precautions you should follow when using a screw extractor to minimize the risk of injury or damage to the surrounding materials. First, always wear appropriate safety gear, such as gloves and eye protection, to protect yourself from any debris or sharp edges that may be produced during the extraction process. 2) Ensure that the tool is firmly secured and locked to avoid any accidental release of the clamping mechanism;
3) Double-check the screw’s position, stability, and overall condition before attempting to extract it, as incorrect or misaligned screws can result in damaged surfaces and make it difficult to reinstall the new screw later on; and 4) Always follow the manufacturer’s instructions and safety guidelines provided in the user manual to ensure proper use and minimize the risk of accidents.

By being cautious and observant while using a screw extractor, you’ll be able to work efficiently and safely, minimizing any potential harm or damage to yourself or the materials you are working with. Follow the tips above, and always prioritize your safety first when working with any tools, including screw extractors.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Sign up to discover human stories that deepen your understanding of the world.

Free

Distraction-free reading. No ads.

Organize your knowledge with lists and highlights.

Tell your story. Find your audience.

Membership

Read member-only stories

Support writers you read most

Earn money for your writing

Listen to audio narrations

Read offline with the Medium app

--

--

Shelly Anderson
Shelly Anderson

No responses yet

Write a response